Lisa Robbin Young

Who are you when no one is watching?


I was sitting at my desk, doing my "usual" routine - the seemingly endless loop of "productive" things like email, writing, researching.

Yet, I couldn't shake this restless thought, pounding in my head:

“Is THIS what it's all come to in 50 years on planet earth?”

This year has been a wild ride, to say the least. Choosing to leave Indiana. Packing everything that would fit in a 5x7 storage pod (and selling or donating everything else) to come about 2,000 miles to the other side of the continent. Navigating my husband's health: 4 heart procedures, a neck injury, a diagnosis of and surgery for thyroid cancer, all in less than 6 months' time.

Oh... and I was supposed to be running my business, too?

Something had to change. I felt like I was living under a rock and I was pretty sure everyone was slowly losing interest in anything I had done or would be doing in the future.

Momentum matters. It's what keeps the "marketing machine" moving along. When you lose momentum, or can't capitalize on it when you've got it, things stall, slow down, and you basically have to start all over again.

Or at least it sure feels that way.

Visibility does not equal (real) influence

Sure, there's that old saw about how people learn by watching you. So there's some truth to the idea that visibility and influence are connected, but visibility for visibility's sake keeps leaders performing for appearances - draining energy, and losing trust in themselves and their teams.

When people believe visibility is leadership, you see things like:

  • Choosing optics over substance. Prioritizing what looks good (a polished video, flashy slide deck) instead of what's actually aligned with capacity or what moves your work forward.
  • Overperforming in public moments but underinvesting in behind-the-scenes work (systems, rest, foundational clarity). Because the visible wins get rewarded, everything else feels less valuable—even if it’s more important.
  • Saying “yes” to panels, summits, interviews, speaking spots, social posts → even when those things drain energy, distract from focus, or don’t match your real business priorities. Because visibility feels like credibility.
  • Masking vulnerability or hiding limits, because leaders feel pressure to appear perfect so as not to lose respect or authority.
  • Being performative in small things: using corporate or leadership jargon, following what “looks like a leader” rather than what feels aligned; making gestures of leadership that are surface-level instead of rooted in values.
  • You care more what people see than what people feel. E.g. you spend hours curating your LinkedIn post, but skip the team follow-up email that really matters.

With the rise of influencer culture, this is an easy trap to fall into.

I've been doing deeper work on what I call your Conditions For Success. It's a topic I've touched on in planning workshops over the years. When you know the conditions that set you up for success, it gives you more power to create or establish those conditions for yourself in an intentional way.

Your Conditions for Success aren’t just about energy, tools, or mindset—they include the world you choose to live and work in. Sometimes, the smartest move isn’t more effort, it’s moving toward contexts that naturally amplify your zone of genius or your ability to find success for yourself or your work.

And while I understand that not everyone has the ability to just up and leave where they are for more favorable conditions, the awareness that a better environment may exist is still important.

But in all my time researching and teaching, I missed something critical: identity alignment—how your internal sense of self matches how you act in work, relationships, and decisions (or doesn't). I'm fixing that now, by looking at why people who don't experience success may actually be grappling with Identity issues that we'd never considered before. Call it my own bias, or ignorance, this new research has helped me see just how important our sense of identity is in our sense of accomplishment and feelings of success.

The Tension Leaders Feel When They Focus Only on Performance

I've known plenty of folks, and heard a number of stories about people who have wealth, power, prestige - all the outward trappings of success - yet they still feel miserable and unsuccessful. It seems obvious now that these folks were some how out of alignment, but I didn't get that it might be an identity issue. Checking all the boxes of "visible" success doesn't always equate to feeling successful or having an experience of success. I never realized that folks who weren't seeing that visible level of success may also be having a similar struggle.

If you're a leader who's stuck on "performance at all costs" you're running up against energetic, ethical, relational, and operational tensions that are likely to break you. You probably feel like you've got to be "on" all the time - or the house of cards will crumble. The research confirms what we already know: high stakes + high pressure + long hours leads to emotional exhaustion, reduced cognitive clarity, and eventually, burnout.

Let me be clear: wearing masks to get through a tough spot in your life or work can be useful. It's not always safe for you to be yourself, out loud an on purpose - especially if you're in an marginalized identity group.

Putting on a happy face when you are going through it can keep your clients or team members from unnecessary worry. But when your internal sense of self is misaligned with your external actions (especially if it's a chronic, continuous state of affairs), it can lead to:

  • Burnout and fatigue
  • Decision paralysis
  • Reduced energy and motivation

When you can show up and get to be your full self (warts, sparkles, and all, as I like to say), you’re more likely to experience:

  • Greater clarity and confidence
  • Improved decision-making
  • Enhanced focus and satisfaction

There's a TON of research to support this. Research also shows that being able to be your authentic self helps you lead your team members more effectively. But if you focus too much on short-term gains, and less on the long-term well-being of everyone (you, the team, the company), trust erodes and burnout sets in.

I get it. In our current political climate, there are a lot of short-term, immediate fires that need putting out. It's really hard to think about the long-term effects of anything when federal agents descend on your neighborhood and/or start rounding up folks who look like you.

The key is to strike the balance between your immediate need and the long-term vision you have in mind.

It's easy to forget. I sure did.

I was SO focused on getting moved, getting settled, making sure that my partner was healthy, that I had all I could do to see clients, never mind the other demands of my business! I managed to compete season 8 of Creative Freedom and have been faithful in filming for the reality show I'm working on, but there hasn't been much more than that going on for a while because of, well... (gestures wildly through the air) all this "life" that's been happening!

By tuning into identity alignment, you take a first step toward:

  • Decisions that feel natural and effortless
  • Energy that doesn’t require constant willpower
  • Leadership that is authentic, resonant, and effective

When you're out of alignment, trust drops. One look at the political landscape today and you see what I mean.  

In a spring 2025 survey by the Partnership for Public Service, only one-third of Americans (33%) said they trust the federal government. Nearly half (47%) said they do not trust it. Further, two-thirds of Americans (67%) believed the federal government was corrupt, and 61% saw it as wasteful. A May 2024 Pew Research Center poll showed similarly low figures, with only 22% of adults trusting the government to do what is right most of the time. An August 2025 U.S. News & World Report survey found that 85% of Americans believe politicians and community leaders care more about their own power than the public's interest.

An article out of Cambridge revealed that When leaders don’t align what they say (visible leadership) and what they do, perceived authenticity and trust drop. This one from ScienceDirect says that your team (your audience) can smell the hypocrisy a mile away. You're not fooling anyone when you're being performative - at least, not for long.

I'd go a step further to say it's not just with your audience, but also with yourself. This sense of self-betrayal leads you to stop believing yourself, second-guessing yourself, and eventually, just giving up on yourself... and your dreams.

Ouch.

Using Conditions For Success to find alignment

When I'm working with clients, we use a 4-step process:

  • Find Your Boosters – Identify what strengthens your leadership and energy when no one’s watching.
  • Find Your Blockers – Recognize behaviors, habits, or pressures that drain your integrity or alignment.
  • Build Your Map – Map out how your private choices influence public results and leadership presence.
  • Apply & Adapt – Implement the map in daily decisions and adjust based on real-world feedback.

Inside Conditions for Success, the Core Domain is the one that deals with your sense of purpose and identity. These are the things we have the most control over. Notice I didn't say TOTAL control over. We can decide how we want to show up in the world and who we want to be. We can seek to align our identity and purpose in the world in ways that others have little to no direct control over. But we are interacting in the world, and we have commitments, obligations, and identities that are not always going to be aligned with what predominant culture is asking of us. It's then that we have to make choices about where we will or won't compromise.

Those compromises are what set us up to potentially be out of alignment. Again, that's not to say all compromises are bad or wrong - very often they are survival skills. But it's unsustainable to LIVE that way for very long.

How You Can Check Whether a Choice Reflects Authentic Leadership

If the decision leads to confusion, skepticism, or dissonance in your relationships or team, it might not be truly aligned - or you may have been wearing a mask for so long that people around you don't know how to deal with this "new you". Here are some questions you can use to prime the pump:

“Does this choice come from my core values, or is it a reaction to others’ expectations?"
If you feel a sense of resistance, that’s probably a signal that something is off.

“Would I stand by this choice if someone asked me why I made it?”
If you find yourself holding back explanation or feeling defensive, that’s a red flag.

“Did I consider diverse perspectives, especially dissenting ones, before deciding?”
If you ignored feedback or dismissed counterarguments lightly, the choice may not be fully authentic.

"Am I aware of my motives, strengths, and limitations in this decision?”
If your decision feels reactive, emotionally heavy, or clouded by fear rather than clarity, that’s a sign to pause.

“Will this decision stand when pressures increase?”
If the decision only “works” now but collapses under stress, it may be more performative than authentic.

“Does this choice build or erode trust in me (internally or among others)?”

Because authentic leaders act in line with who they are, their followers tend to see that consistency, which builds trust (source).

When you're looking more closely at your identity, try these:

  • “Who am I when I’m not performing for anyone?”
  • “What version of me feels alive and true right now?”
  • "Is there a gap between who I really am and what I think i need to be?"

Journal Freely: Let thoughts and feelings flow without judgment.
You'll start to reveal patterns in your energy, decisions, and relationships. Over time, it can show where alignment is strong—and where external pressures may be pulling you off-center.

The goal is to keep moving closer to your truth. As I said before, total control - perfection is impossible unless you live in a vacuum. But striving for alignment helps you feel more successful in the moment. As I've said many times before, success is a destination and you're already there!

You might also like:

There are worse things I could do than niching (parody from the movie Grease)

READ NOW

You're smart, so why are you still struggling? Here's 10 good reasons

READ NOW

Being Self-Made is a Myth [Creative Freedom S4E8]

READ NOW